How Reliable are Model Diagnostics?

Findings (ACL) 2021 · Vamsi Aribandi, Yi Tay, Donald Metzler ·

In the pursuit of a deeper understanding of a model's behaviour, there is recent impetus for developing suites of probes aimed at diagnosing models beyond simple metrics like accuracy or BLEU. This paper takes a step back and asks an important and timely question: how reliable are these diagnostics in providing insight into models and training setups? We critically examine three recent diagnostic tests for pre-trained language models, and find that likelihood-based and representation-based model diagnostics are not yet as reliable as previously assumed. Based on our empirical findings, we also formulate recommendations for practitioners and researchers.