Sparkly: A Simple yet Surprisingly Strong TF/IDF Blocker for Entity Matching

Blocking is a major task in entity matching. Numerous blocking solutions have been developed, but as far as we can tell, blocking using the well-known tf/idf measure has received virtually no attention. Yet, when we experimented with tf/idf blocking using Lucene, we found it did quite well. So in this paper we examine tf/idf blocking in depth. We develop Sparkly, which uses Lucene to perform top-k tf/idf blocking in a distributed share-nothing fashion on a Spark cluster. We develop techniques to identify good attributes and tokenizers that can be used to block on, making Sparkly completely automatic. We perform extensive experiments showing that Sparkly outperforms 8 state-of-the-art blockers. Finally, we provide an in-depth analysis of Sparkly's performance, regarding both recall/output size and runtime. Our findings suggest that (a) tf/idf blocking needs more attention, (b) Sparkly forms a strong baseline that future blocking work should compare against, and (c) future blocking work should seriously consider top-k blocking, which helps improve recall, and a distributed share-nothing architecture, which helps improve scalability, predictability, and extensibility.

PDF Abstract

Results from the Paper


Task Dataset Model Metric Name Metric Value Global Rank Benchmark
Blocking Abt-Buy Sparkly k=10 Recall 98.1 # 3
Candidate Set Size 10900 # 4
Blocking Abt-Buy Sparkly k=50 Recall 99.2 # 2
Candidate Set Size 54500 # 6
Blocking Amazon-Google Sparkly k=10 Recall 96.8 # 6
Candidate Set Size 33300 # 2
Blocking Amazon-Google Sparkly k=50 Recall 99.2 # 2
Candidate Set Size 165900 # 6

Methods


No methods listed for this paper. Add relevant methods here